Hello dear
Welcome To Main Street Pizza Lake Placid
Welcome to Main Street Pizza Lake Placid, a hidden gem nestled at 2673 Main St, Lake Placid, NY. This charming pizzeria, celebrated for its authentic Long Island pizza, prides itself on a friendly, family-run atmosphere. Owner James crafts each pie with passion, ensuring every bite is indulgently fresh. Patrons rave about the Grandma’s Pie, boasting a perfect balance of flavors that keeps them returning. The quality and dedication at Main Street Pizza elevate it above the rest, making it a must-visit for both locals and visitors alike. Don’t miss the chance to experience this delightful pizza haven!
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
About
Main Street Pizza Lake Placid
Welcome to Main Street Pizza Lake Placid, a hidden gem located at 2673 Main St, Lake Placid, NY. As a passionate food reviewer for Foodjoyy, I had the pleasure of diving deep into what makes this eatery stand out in a town known for its stunning landscapes and vibrant community. The welcoming atmosphere and the aroma of freshly baked pizzas invite you in, setting the stage for a delightful culinary experience.
At the helm of this establishment is owner James, a dedicated craftsman who infuses each pizza with genuine passion and authenticity. Guests are often greeted with warmth and an open conversation, making it a personal experience rather than just a meal. It’s not just a dining spot; it’s a slice of Long Island brought to the heart of Lake Placid.
The star of the show here is undoubtedly the pizza. Customers rave about the grandma's pie, described as indulgent yet fresh—an absolute must-try for any pizza lover. The balance of flavors and textures is nothing short of heavenly, with cheese melting perfectly over a crisp crust. Reviewers like Maya Rain have called it some of the best pizza they've ever tasted, and I wholeheartedly agree with that sentiment.
What sets Main Street Pizza apart is the authenticity echoed in every bite. Chris Lake, another satisfied patron, highlights the pure essence of Long Island pizza that you can find here. The commitment to quality shines through, making each bite a nostalgic journey for many locals and travelers alike.
Despite its unassuming exterior, don’t let appearances fool you. Heather Diaz's testimony emphasizes how this one-man show can deliver incredible gastronomic delights quickly—even during the busiest times before local events like hockey games. The pepperoni grandma's pizza received high praise, boasting both flavor and prompt service that left everyone satisfied.
Even though the wait might be longer for a perfect pizza, as mentioned by Dimitre Iliev, it’s a reminder that great things take time. The pizza here truly melts in your mouth—a testament to James's dedication to quality and fresh ingredients.
In a town bustling with outdoor activities and events, Main Street Pizza Lake Placid stands out not just for its delicious offerings but for its commitment to creating a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, make sure to stop by, indulge in their mouthwatering pizzas, and soak up the welcoming atmosphere. This is a culinary experience that should not be missed when in Lake Placid.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I was in town for the marathon and stumbled upon this place. Owner was extremely friendly and dedicated to his craft. Great pizza! Will be back next year for more ”
“ Super good pizza!! Some of the best I’ve had. We got the grandmas pie and it was so indulgent but still fresh - perfect! The place was empty when we went in so we were sure, but so worth staying. Best pizza in Lake Placid for sure ”
“ Pure authentic Long Island pizza at its best! If you’re lucky enough to have a conversation with the owner, James, you will be all the better for it! Places this authentic and genuine are not easy to come by these days. ”
“ One man show, didn't disappoint. Went in before a hockey game as all other restaurants were packed. Within 15 minutes we were enjoying a grandma's pizza with pepperoni. It was delicious. Left with our bellies filled. Don't underestimate by the looks. This place is serving it up. ”
“ I recently tried the best pizza in town at a local restaurant. The pizza melted in my mouth and was delicious despite taking a bit longer to make. Highly recommend for a delicious pizza experience! ”
“ Placed a large delivery order recently with Main Street Pizza and it did not disappoint! We got 7 pies (plain, buffalo, pepperoni, white) and they were all enjoyed by our large group! We also got a tray of Caesar salad and 2 orders of garlic knots (so good!). 10/10 recommend Main Street Pizza to anyone visiting Lake Placid! ”
“ Main Street Pizza did an amazing job having a huge 60 person order on time and piping hot on a Saturday night at prime time. Great pizza, chicken fingers and salad. Pleasant to deal with as well. ”
“ Large cheese pizza tonight was ready at time promised for pick-up. We asked for a thinner crust which was very good. The cheese had nice soft texture and taste. Last-minute ordered garlic knots were fresh/puffy with good flavor. I am a pizza snob (Staten Island, Bklyn, NJ). I'd order here again. It's not fancy inside. I hate too much oregano; this pizza had just a touch. I don't know if other reviewers hit on an off night but we were happy. ”